Fair Flora⤴

from

296/365 Fair Flora
296/365 Fair Flora flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

When I was about eight years old our parents sold our family home and bought a plot of land that had once been part of an orchard. We had a static caravan which was towed onto a corner of the land and there we all lived – mum, dad and 4 children aged 8-4 – for 16 months while we built our new house on that land. It was difficult for us, as children, I cannot imagine how hard it was for my parents. But the house that we built was wonderful and we were all very happy there.

At some point after we moved in my mum got a visit from one of the local ‘characters’ – and old lady called Annie (was she once the post mistress, maybe – my memory is hazy and there’s nobody left to ask). Annie asked mum if she’d like a statue for the garden. Of course mum said yes, she was never one to turn down a free gift. So Annie turned up, under the cover of darkness, with a wheelbarrow containing a bundle wrapped in cloth. She tipped this out, unceremoniously, nearly toppling it into the burn in the corner of our garden (I was distraught as I was hoping that there might be frogs in that water!).

And so Fair Flora arrived, complete with a legend as told by Annie – of a maiden who haunted the woods over the village of Eyam (close to where we lived) and a statue in her honour liberated from one of the nearby stately homes – maybe Stoke Hall?

I don’t remember whether she was ever outside in our Derbyshire garden, but she travelled down south with us and stood in the hallway, draped in our coats. When mum and dad moved later she was consigned to their potting shed, and then I liberated her and brought her up to Scotland.

Now she sits in the corner of our patio, and she makes me very happy.

#altc25 Glasgow Conference Reflections⤴

from @ ...........Experimental Blog

Decompressing from some excellent days at the Association for Learning Technology's annual conference in Glasgow. Here are some quick reflections on what I picked up. Programme was great (as co-chair some bias in that) and I probably missed many other useful nuggets. Thought venue and catering etc all excellent. Company as ever was splendid. I even managed to appear on ALTC Radio. 

Great to work with team at ALT and my co chairs to pull things together. I hope everyone had a great time 

Preconference Evening in NQ64

Looked inspired had a previous engagement but what a fun place. Made me think about Reclaim Hosting folks and other edtechs I know who collect, repair and build gaming machines as a hobby.

Day One 

Charles Knight 

Great keynote and call to action. Learning Technologists do , do magic - but they do need the right context. Good institutions succeed by giving staff and students agency and confidence and this is still possible in period of massive change. Good advice too though if magic is not achievable where you are move on to the next gig and light up another room.

Publication of New Jisc Beyond Blended Report and Assets 

An open set of resources and report to improve learning design across the sector. These can be repurposed and made your own. So well done on creative commons licence. Would be great to see QAA, SFC , HMIE were directing centres to resources like this.  Blended is about taking a whole institutional approach including working on co-creation with learners to improve the learning experience. All directors of teaching and learning, faculty heads and quality managers etc should know their way around this. 

Mark Bush - Inspera

Mainly a session around how to trust suppliers. An old chestnut. But sensing a market maturity in lots of discussions with suppliers and exhibitors over the two days of the conference. New entrants need to have a better solution to displace incumbents. As there is less money about, the sector generally tends to be much more risk adverse and not as willing to pilot new things and there is a constant concern about lock in (once you are on board, will tolls , licence fees simply climb with no clear escape route) or perhaps this is just a timely awareness. 

Where in Scotland APUC, in UK UCISA and organisations like ALT come in.  We do all talk to each other about suppliers and possible technical solutions.  

Online assessment systems like Inspera now handling 18.2 million submissions a year and operating in 26 countries globally.

Student Panel 

Was interesting as ever to hear level headed students taking a measured approach to AI adoption and mainly asking for more support around academic writing. And not really having clear answer on what is best way to communicate with them.

Edgehill University  

Attended interesting sessions on blended learning and costings.  The current ABC model struggles with spiral curriculums that exist in medicine and some other disciplines so does need different approach while keeping a laser like focus on not overloading students with content.  Edge Hill University has some useful resources to support collaborative development. 

University of Southampton

The University of Southampton have created a useful tool for helping with very vague faculty requests to create digital learning materials. Looks great it creates resource allocations. costs and realistic delivery timelines. I do hope academics take time to fill in the forms in properly.

University of Leeds 

Good story where learning technology was pulled back from faculties to become more centralised service- became design led strategic partners with much better focus on educational enhancement framework using institutional data to target academic teams that needed support.

Did a quick change and had great fun at dinner, awards ceremony and  Ceilidh - band were great and still home by 11pm. Congratulations to all winners and nominees. 

Day Two 

Launch of AmplifyFE Impact  Report

It was a privilege to get to say a few words and launch the #AmplifyFE impact report. Led in partnership with ALT and the UFI Vocational Trust it now embraces a community of around 3700 practitioners from across the UK.  A few more FE folks in Scotland should tune into this network. 


Gabbi Witthaus 

So grounded and so human. I do wonder that system still can seem so rigid, remote and hostile to learners.  Four dimensions work is really useful way to help teachers and students manage life and learning loads. Gabbi has kindly shared her keynote. 


Edinburgh Napier and Sciaten Partners

Great work around ethical use of AI with academics and students. Great too to see Open Scotland referenced in influences here. Some really useful resources to open up discussions about AI in curriculum and assessment here.  

Would be good to see more Scottish Colleges visible in supporting this work. 


Paul Basich

Great session focussing on efficient ways of delivering blended learning. It is mostly common sense - but staggering to hear that some large institutions are just beginning to think about institutional templates in virtual learning environments etc. In some respects HE has a lot to learn about course design, teaching and learning from Colleges. In feedback highlighted that West Lancashire College has delivered to 10,000 online  learners in last 5 years - part of Newcastle College Group. 


ALT Strategy Session
Sort of what it said on the tin - in a world where everyone is now an 'expert on digital learning'  ALT needs to keep ahead of the pack. 

University of Glasgow - Jenny Crow

A nice bit of work echoing the mornings keynote and some of the themes from the student panel around experiments using whatsapp and other platforms to give learners a solid sense of belonging

Manchester Met - Andrew Larner

Great tool for suggesting new assessment designs using generative AI from Manchester Metropolitan University. Really worth exploring.

Exhibitors etc 

Great to see many established players and a number of new potential suppliers for Education sector - I did get around and say hello. 

Good to have lots of proper dialogues around sectoral challenges that were way beyond the 'sales patter' of old. Among the VLE suppliers still some frustration that institutions are not 'sweating' the assets and doing more with the great platforms that are available. 

Good to meet the team from Brickfield and hear about their tools for monitoring the accessibility of learning content.

Interested in Edina's new walled garden for trying out AI tools.

A shout out to Vevox their polling solution worked very well throughout the conference.

Nice to meet Estendio, Eduface, and Study Stash all harnessing AI to improve teaching and learning.

Endnotes 

It was great to have a number of colleagues along from City of Glasgow College but I do think Colleges generally should be more engaged with ALT and communities of practice. I'll keep pushing through ALT Scotland , CDN and the work with Jisc that is already in place. 

I miss social media Discord was ok but needs everyone on board. Remember you are all agents of change. Find each other on social media @joecar80.bsky.social

I listed seven things for delegates 

  1. (Beyond) Blended Learning is the future !

  2. Is your own practice open ? (Discover Open Scotland )

  3. I hope you are all blogging and aggregating (ScotEdublogs) 

  4. It ain’t a microcredential without a digital badge ( using 1Edtech open standards) and a platform that supports these. 

  5. Hope you have figured out how to allow learners and staff to use AI ethically. Local models are the way ahead for many. 

  6. In a world where everyone is now an expert on educational technology – ALT continues to be beacon in the darkness.

  7. I hope you enjoyed Glasgow and haste ye back. 





College leaders are right to stand up for students and the taxpayer⤴

from

To The Editor,

COLLEGE leaders are to be applauded for taking a tough stance against college lecturers who take part in another marking boycott ("Colleges agree plan to dock pay from staff who take part in marking boycott", The Herald, February 10). It's about time somebody in this country stood up to out-of-control trade unions.

Following their long summer holiday last year, FE lecturers mounted a similar resulting boycott. They did so because they were dissatisfied with the arrangement which sees the taxpayer fund them to have 13 weeks' holiday per year. They were further dissatisfied that they earn only £40,000 compared to Scotland's median gross annual salary for full-time workers, which is £33,332. And they were even further dissatisfied with their chalk-face workload of 20-odd hours per week. They were dissatisfied then, and they're dissatisfied still. I've come to the conclusion that they will never be satisfied, and that they will always come back for more.

The consequence of last year's resulting boycott by well-salaried, superannuated lecturers was that young people's lives were put on hold because they couldn't complete their apprenticeships. The boycott similarly stopped first-year construction apprentices, who barely earn £6 per hour, from progressing to their next stage and receiving a £2p/h wage rise for which they'd worked all year. Everything and everyone was to wait until the lecturers got more. In the topsy-turvy world of progressive politics it's Mr Bumble who demands more from Oliver. What is in the interests of apprentices, their families and their employers was simply a means to the lecturers' end. And the end is, more. More, more, more. And when they get it, they still want more.

Now they want to do the same thing again. So it's right that college leaders stand up for the taxpayer as well as their students. But perhaps more radical solutions need to be considered. Perhaps the argument for the development of technical schools could simply do away with the need for a college sector altogether. Perhaps the taxpayer could do more with less.

Yours sincerely, 

...


https://www.heraldscotland.com/opinion/24115159.college-leaders-right-stand-students-taxpayer/


Combining Interleaving and the Spacing Effect, Part 2⤴

from @ Memory and Metacognition Updates

Hello! Last time I shared the research of Birnbaum and colleagues on spacing and interleaving. This paper helped to show that interleaving is not a side effect of the spacing effect, but is in fact due to a separate mechanism – the benefits of contrasting one item with another.

When the researchers put gaps in between contrasting items in their experiment, they found that far from boosting the interleaving effect, it actually removed it, causing interleaved and blocked lists to be learned at the same rate.

The researchers observed (p, 399):

“The optimal way to study was not to combine spacing and interleaving, because spacing seemed to interrupt discrimination processing. This finding has a practical message: It is crucial, in inductive learning, to juxtapose examples of different categories.”

So, in short, you can’t do interleaving without contrast.

Implications for the classroom

The findings of this research showed that contrasting items is important to interleaving.

This, I think, has been supported by subsequent work over the last decade or so, and applies to both new learning (such as when we see multiple items from different categories and need to learn the difference between them) and practice of previously-learned skills (e.g. interleaved practice problems in maths or science).

However, the spacing effect and distributed practice is also a valuable, evidence-based strategy. So, how do we reconcile these things?

The answer is that we can combine spacing and interleaving, but we need to do it in a way that doesn’t mess up the contrast between items. Scheduling gaps indiscriminately is not always going to help.


Multiple red alarm clocks strewn across a blue background
Indiscriminate clocks. Image via Pixabay.

Guidance for pedagogy

You’ll be relieved to know that there is a simple solution to the problem of combining interleaving and spacing. The key is to avoid putting gaps of time (or scheduling other tasks) in between contrasting items.

Consider these two options, bearing in mind that A and B are different categories that we want students to contrast:

Version 1: AA – short delay – BB – short delay – AA – short delay – BB

Version 1: AB – short delay – AB – short delay – AB – short delay – AB

Consider version 1. Perhaps here we have an elementary teacher whose class are practising two types of maths problems on the same day, but doing each type in a small group, then having a break and then tackling the second type of problem. In this example, the teacher may believe that their class are interleaving practice. However, the format is cutting down on contrast, and perhaps (in line with the Birnbaum study) having no benefit.

In version 2, we see that contrast is ensured in each example or short practice session. This could involve the same elementary teacher, but this time their class don’t work on small blocks of problems on the same day; each problem is side-by-side with a contrasting problem.

Another example could be a lecturer who shares examples in their lecture. If their examples all focus on the same concept, then the contrast is reduced (assuming that some time passes before the next lecture). To improve on this, the lecturer could share the same examples, but do so in a way that different concepts are directly contrasted within the same lecture.

As a general rule, practice the material in an interleaved contrast, then have a delay of some form, and then have further interleaved practice of the same concepts.

A brief note on interleaving by lesson or topic

If you had assumed that interleaving involves covering different topic in the same day or week, you might be wondering about the implications of what I have just said.

Now, certainly teachers can interleave in this way. However, we need to pay some attention to where the contrasts lie. How often are students experiencing contrasting concepts/skills side by side?

If the topics are covered in the same day but with a delay in between (e.g. reptiles in the morning, amphibians in the afternoon) then it may be that the lack of direct contrast negates some of the benefits.

However, this may also depend on the materials, and on how easy it is for learners to retain the details over a delay. If you have a schedule from your own teaching that you’d be happy to share in the comments, I will endeavour to let you know what I think about it!

Enjoy and have a great week.

Jonathan


Last time: Combining Interleaving and the Spacing Effect, part 1


I hope you are enjoying Memory and Metacognition Updates. Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work – and consider sharing it with colleagues!! Thank you!


Creative Commons License

Please note that my slides and similar materials are shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. This means you can use or adapt them with attribution for non-commercial purposes. If you wish to use my materials for other purposes, feel free to get in touch.

The ladder⤴

from @ lenabellina

A shattering fall

From the greatest of heights

Hard to tell, first of all

What was broken.

Nothing was visible on the outside

Yet horrors within

Left unspoken.

Up became down

And down became up 

As she struggled to swim

To the surface. 

Sometimes she sensed

The glow of the sun

But then lost it again

In darkness.

For a while she surrendered 

And let herself drown

In all that she needed to feel.

Hanging there,

Corpse-like

At one with the sea

And heeding the song of the seal.

And slowly the water

And turning of tides

Soothed her body and

Offered a hand.

She dipped her toe out

Of the waters once more

And cautiously stepped

Onto land.

She could not go back

To where she had been

Giddy heights could no longer

Be hers.

And though she felt sadness 

At losing so much 

She felt herself freed from a curse.

The curse of competing 

Of trying so hard

Of needing to always be more

Without ever feeling enough 

Or on top

Without ever touching the core.

The core of her being 

The core of her soul 

The song of her true voice and heart 

The core which had never

Been seen, heard or loved

But covered by part after part. 

Parts trying to help her

Each in its own way

By managing, fixing and more

But all the time taking

Her further away

From the solid, safe ground 

Of the shore.

She walks under ladders

These days

Without fear

And keeping her feet firmly below.

She walks with her head up

With eyes shining bright

The way of the healer who knows.