Athena Swan win -assessment and feedback⤴

from @ Melissa Highton

I am delighted that my team in LTW at University of Edinburgh have gained a Bronze Athena Swan Award. I bet we are the first learning technology department in a UK university to do so. We are certainly the first professional services department  at Edinburgh to achieve it.  We got great feedback from the assessment panel.

The panel is satisfied that the application adequately addresses the award criteria and is pleased to confer a Bronze Athena Swan award.

The panel commends the leadership and senior buy-in which is evident in several ways, including:

·       the strong letter of endorsement from the Director which communicates a solid organisational commitment to Athena Swan and demonstrates a clear understanding of the importance of Equality, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI) in improving service delivery and experience for all – the inclusion of Directorate initiatives in Institutional Athena Swan applications underscores the value of the work being undertaken (pp.5-6);

·       the Director’s personal leadership and active development of a range of EDI-related initiatives (pp.9-12);

·       resourcing a Data and Equality Officer (DEO) post which includes responsibilities to support EDI work, for example, reporting Directorate /user demographic data to the Senior Management Team (SMT) and maintaining the EDI newsletter (p.9);

·       senior management representation on the Directorate’s Self-Assessment Team (SAT), including the Director and the Head of Operations (pp.14-15);

·       recognition and reward of EDI work through both local (e.g., digital badges) and University recognition mechanisms (e.g., vouchers, annual review process, pp.10-11).

A clear governance structure for EDI is in place with accountability lying with senior colleagues (p.9). The panel commends the purposeful design of structures and processes to embed EDI in decision-making and in the culture of the Directorate, for example, the establishment of roles which explicitly involve EDI, the Dignity and Respect Advisor is a member of the SMT and Athena Swan will be a standing item at SMT meetings (pp.9-10, p.17, p.44). The links between the Directorate’s EDI work and University EDI governance structures appear strong, for example, the Director is a member of the University EDI Committee and the DEO sits on the University Equality and Diversity Monitoring and Reporting Committee (EDMARC) (p.9); these links ensure that the Directorate’s EDI/gender equality work is aligned with institutional strategy as well as providing opportunities for broader collaboration.

Similarly, processes for policy development and evaluation, including feedback routes, appear robust (p.13). The Directorate uses Equality Impact Assessments in respect of local policy/practice and staff perceptions of being informed about University policies relating to EDI are largely positive (although there is a disparity between male/female responses, p.13).

The SAT brings diversity of perspectives, including representatives from component teams and with different lived experience of members; the recruitment process, comprising expressions of interest combined with targeted invitations to ensure that the SAT reflects the diversity of the Directorate, is commended (pp.14-15).

A transparent account of the activities of the SAT from its inception until finalisation of the application, including a timeline (table 3), is provided (pp.16-17). Multiple data sources informed the self-assessment and a range of approaches have been utilised to capture the voices of the Directorate’s community (p.16). The Directorate’s plans to monitor and implement the action plan, which will be overseen by the SAT, appear robust and are commended (p.17).

As a result of a thorough analysis of the mandatory data and a critical evaluation of culture, a wide range of gender equality issues are identified (pp.18-26). The panel commends the:

·       range of activity to develop a positive and supportive culture, including Mandatory Training Day, Friday messages, events for Ada Lovelace Day, EDI reading groups and promoting the University’s Don’t Cross the Line campaign (pp.23-26). The impact of these activities is evident in positive feedback about the culture of the Directorate (e.g., 83% of respondents to the EDI survey ‘felt the workplace was inclusive’, p.23);

·       collection and analysis of data on contribution awards and pay;

·       evidence-based and thoughtful approach to the use of a variety of benchmarks to support a nuanced analysis of the gender equality issues facing the Directorate.

The panel congratulates the Directorate on achieving a Bronze award.

 Good practice examples highlighted

The panel considers the Directorate’s approach, led by the Wikimedian in Residence, to diversify Wikipedia writers and content, to be good practice. The Resident Wikimedian hosts regular events and workshops to train staff and students to edit Wikipedia entries and write articles to increase the diversity of subject and contributors (p.25). This work has been impactful in raising the profile of the limitations of Wikipedia (particularly to students), addressing the gender bias in whose stories are disseminated online and improving around 16,000 articles.

The panel also considers the PlayFair Steps initiative, including EDI recognition badges, to be good practice (pp.10-11).

More broadly, the panel commends the thoughtful consideration with which a variety of sector, discipline and regional benchmarks are used.

Rhythms Of Water⤴

from

Journeys
Journeys flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Along a busy road cars whizz past, their engines buzzing in my ears
The water moves slowly, lapping over small rocks
Birds flit, silently, through the trees
Dogs bark, owners wander by smiling and raising a hand
Different paces, different rhythms, different worlds

TDC5031

Combining Interleaving and the Spacing Effect, Part 1⤴

from @ Memory and Metacognition Updates

Hello!

In a couple of recent posts I explored research that has investigated the combination of two evidence-based learning techniques: retrieval practice, and generative learning (find the posts here and here).

I mentioned in passing that even when pedagogical techniques are effective, combinations of two or more techniques don’t automatically help. I give the example of interleaving and spacing. As one reader rightly pointed out to me, this deserves further explanation!

Spacing and interleaving

First, a very brief recap:

  • The spacing effect relates to improved learning when practice is distributed widely over time, such that there are gaps between one practice session and the next. For example, a child learning spelling would be better to practice for 10 minutes per day over six days than to practice for one hour on a single day, even though the overall study time is the same. More information here: update #39.

  • Interleaving relates to the order of items and the contrast between them. When you practice multiple similar types of items (e.g. maths problems focusing on the same skill, or examples of the same concept), this is a blocked study session. When you practice items from different skills or categories such that each item has a different type of item before and after, this is an interleaved study session. More here: update #96.

Thus, spacing and interleaving are not the same thing.

It would be possible for an interleaved study session to be more or less spaced over time, while spacing practice would be possible without interleaving that practice.


a traditional ornate pocket watch, open and lying on a wooden surface
Image via Pixabay

Combining the two

So, why did I suggest that combining spacing and interleaving could cause problems?

This was explored by researchers Monica Birnbaum and colleagues. The study focused on the idea that interleaving helps because it contrasts items from different categories. This contrast is, according to many researchers, the reason why interleaving helps (an idea known as the discrimination-contrast hypothesis).

However, other researchers had reasoned that interleaving helps mainly because it adds a very short delay between one item and the next. If item A is presented in a block (A – A – A) then the gap between two examples is shorter (less spaced) than if it is interspersed with other categories (e.g., A – B – C – A – B – C – etc).

So, what matters – the contrast or the delay? To test this, Birnbaum and colleagues inserted additional delays between items, so that learners either saw contrasting items close together (examples from category A, B, C, etc), or with a brief delay in between the items, achieved by inserting 10-second trivia questions, like so:

Condition 1: A – B – C – etc

Condition 2: A – question – B – question – C – etc

If delays are the cause of the interleaving benefit, condition 2 should do better. But if contrast is what matters, condition 1 should be superior, and this is in fact what the researchers found.

In condition 2 (with delays), the advantage of interleaving disappeared – it was no better than blocking. It appeared that rather than helping (via spacing), short gaps had actually spoiled the contrast.

Below is the reference and a link to the paper (my description above focuses especially on experiment 2):


Birnbaum, M. S., Kornell, N., Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2013). Why interleaving enhances inductive learning: The roles of discrimination and retrieval. Memory & Cognition, 41(3), 392–402.


This is one of these cases where I am surprised to realise that I haven’t shared a paper sooner – it’s such an important one. I will say more about the educational implications next time!

Enjoy and have a great week.

Jonathan


Last time: Does Retrieval Practice Cause Forgetting?


I hope you are enjoying Memory and Metacognition Updates. Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work – and consider sharing it with colleagues!! Thank you!


Creative Commons License

Please note that my slides and similar materials are shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. This means you can use or adapt them with attribution for non-commercial purposes. If you wish to use my materials for other purposes, feel free to get in touch.

An Unofficial Glance at things to get up to in Glasgow #ALTC25⤴

from @ ...........Experimental Blog



 I am co-chairing ALTC25. Conference for UK Association for Learning Technology. I promised a Glasgow post on other attractions. 

There are loads of ways you can find out what is on in Glasgow while you are about for the ALTC Conference. But I thought I'd add my own wee list of places that I like.  Remember I am now a 60 something Glaswegian but I think the fun here can be pretty intergenerational. Whatever your thing is, you will find it in Glasgow. 

Here is a wee very Glasgow playlist of Glaswegian musicians over the years to speed you on way. 

I do hope if you are arriving early on Wednesday you are coming along to Riverside Campus of City of Glasgow College. To see the ships simulators. 

I am big into cultural activities art, theatre and drinking coffee etc too, but you will get these from the internet.  I do recommend the hop on hop off Glasgow City Tour bus as a way to get your bearings. If you are about on Saturday have a look around the Barrows Market in Glasgow's east end. 

Here are a list of eating and drinking spots that  I think are really worth finding and all within  range of  the conference hotel.  You can look them up. I'd catch the subway if going to west end , get on in city centre and get off at Hillhead. You can't get lost, one big circle. 

You can combine visits to these places with more cultural activities. 

City Centre Drinks 

Sloans  - Old coaching house - old intercity coach terminal.

Mono and Stereo -  Two related bars Vegan and Good music 

Potstill - Best Whisky Bar 

Horseshoe Bar - Authentic Victorian Glasgow Bar 

Lauriston Bar - Just across the river - best Guiness and frequented by Indie bands.  

McChuills - live music 

Clutha Vaults - live music 

Scotia Bar - live music 

Del Monicas - live music and dancing 

Buff Club - dancing and new Jazz club 

City Centre Eats 

Brutti Compadres - a bit of eats and drinks in nice old courtyard

Cafe Gandolfi - Up market Glasgow classic for arty folks 

Pisano - best pizza in town and great value 

Sugo - great pasta dishes and great value 

Margot - up market posh nosh 

Dhabba and Dhakin - North and South Indian restaurants near each other

Finnieston and Around - lots of wee bars mainly great eats 

Craab Shakk - tiny atmospheric fish and sea food straight from west highlands. 

Mother India and Mother India Cafe - best Currys in Glasgow - second one is tapas style.

Ox and Finch - very posh nosh and hard to get booking 

The Gannet - posh michelin type but good food.

West End/ Byres Road - near Glasgow University so loads of places to eat and drink

Oran Mhor - old converted church always lots going on 

Tennents Bar - classic Glasgow bar

Ubiquitous Chip - nice bar and posh nosh

Craab Shakk West End - larger sister restaurant of Finnieston one 

There are lots of great places South Side Glasgow too - you can discover them next trip 




#Scotedublogs #openscot – Why you should blog and Why you should join this Aggregator⤴

from @ ...........Experimental Blog


If you dig back in this blog you will see that one way or another I have been blogging since the turn of the century. It's never without its challenges but for me it is a key part of open practice. It is a positive way of moving things forward. 

There was a sudden flowering of the Scottish Educational Blogosphere around 2005. In this context mainly school based folks. One of the great platforms that emerged from that period was and is  #Scotedublogs a simple aggregator of Scottish Educational blogs. 

As an educational blogger it was great to have some company along the way, at least for a short for a while. 

At one point I even managed  find some sponsorship to help it grow.

Championed by John Johnston one of the many unsung heroes in Scottish Education. 

It is probably needed again more than ever.  In time of enshittification etc It is good to have something that anchors the disparate but very authentic voices of those working across or around Scottish Education. We are doing a wee bit of a push to re-build this 'community' of Scottish Edubloggers. 

This sits well with lots of other things I support around Open Education. #openscot 

All you need is a blog or similar with an RSS feed.

And then all you need to do is make sure your blog is listed. 

Here are some suggestions.  

I could go on a bit of a rant 

  1. If you work in and or around Scottish Education you should have a blog or similar.  A critical part of professional development review in my view.
  2. If you train teachers or have a role in developing staff - you should be showing students and staff all how to blog and or create a shareable professional journal.
  3. If you work for General Teaching Council in Scotland you should have made this part of registration a very long time ago.  
  4. I am an old hand and still use Blogger - it serves it's purpose. But if I was to start again I would start by using free wordpress and then migrate to A domain of my own from Reclaim Hosting. ( I have my own domain already).  
  5. Colleges and College staff have been particularly absent from the blogosphere. This currently means the sector is pretty much stifled as there are very few established voices talking about current College challenges in a sensible extended way.  
All I do is publish this blog - as it is listed in Scotedublogs it will appear on feed and be syndicated to Mastodon and Bluesky. 







 

Fixed: PDF Issue⤴

from @ news – Glow Blog Help

The PDF Issue that recently developed on Glow Blogs has now been fixed. PDFs can now be uploaded as expected without any workarounds.

Thanks to all the people who reported it.

If you changed your Resize larger images to setting to zero as a workaround please reset it to the value it had before. 1260 pixels is the default.

Note the behaviour of pasting pdf links into the classic editor has changed. See the PDF page for details of how this works now.