A month ago I got an email from Hollie McNish, after I had volunteered, via a Facebook post, to review the copy proofs of her next collection, Virgin. I didn’t strictly fit the criteria for being a reviewer as my social media following isn’t big enough… but luckily Hollie let me sneak into the circle of the chosen few after I sent a pleading request for special consideration on the basis of my love for her work.
This was enough to make me feel very privileged and all warm-glow-insidey.
This feeling intensified when the proofs arrived and I squirrelled the book into my holiday luggage, ready to read it while away on my summer travels in France.
I sat and read the poems on the 4 and a half hour crossing on the Cherbourg to Poole ferry.
What does it say that I felt I had to keep the book open flat on the table and was too ashamed to expose the cover and Virgin title hidden from onlookers? What does it say that I felt as if I’d be judged, labelled, exposed or deemed guilty of some sort of sex crime for reading a book with a title that could be seen as “inappropriate?”
Does it say something about just me, a recently-departed head teacher, who sometimes felt that others saw her voice as inappropriate but for all the wrong reasons? (When her voice was saying all the right things to protect children but when these things made the system feel inadequate or uncomfortable.)
Maybe. (But oh how just trust me on this speaks to me).
Does it say something about just me, a survivor of sexual abuse, who is still trying to tell her little 7 year old self that what happened wasn’t her fault and can never, ever be excused? (Even if sometimes others try to find excuses or can’t listen because her voice makes them feel uncomfortable.)
Maybe. (But oh how swimming speaks to me).
Does it say something about just me, who because of what happened when I was 7, has lived with a disproportionate sense of shame and guilt and confusion about all things sex and touch and love and spent her teens and early twenties in utter confusion about what was ok and what wasn’t. (And did things that were both.)
Maybe. (But oh how saying no, when you’re nice and polite speaks to me.)
But what it also says is exactly why these poems and collection are so important for our society at this moment in time.
They are absolutely about just me but they are also about us, as living, breathing, sexual, safety-seeking beings. They are intelligent, perceptive, funny, heart-breaking and human poems. At many, many points they had me crying big tears and circling and underlining hard as I read words and lines that had my heart pounding and my voice wanting to shout agreement and understanding and felt-ness.
These are poems that debunk the historic concept that lost virginity is somehow shameful, whoresome and othering. They explore the fate of that much-maligned virgin Mary and all the tortured virgins since, who have been slaughtered instead of supported.
They examine hymens and bike-riding and orifices and consent and lack of consent, where women’s bodies have been seen as the property of men and where laws and society have validated… and continue to validate… this criminality. They are, in many ways, poems of despair.
But they also celebrate Hollie’s genius in re-birthing the virgin so that we can all take pride, from this moment on, in being virgin.
This is a collection that frequently helps us feel connected through our despair at the world, particularly if we succumb to watching the extremes (most people). But these are also poems about love and all the good, joyous stuff in the the world (croissants, warm and making love x 18). They remind us that, too often, our beliefs are influenced by conventions, concepts and a culture created by c***s. (And I’m allowed to use that word because I have one, although I still can’t quite shake off enough shame to be able to write the three missing letters in the starry part.)
I love these poems. I love Hollie for writing them and for giving me a chance to feel seen in my despair and to feel hope at what humans can and could be, if only we challenge the concepts that aren’t good for us.
My favourites?
call me – for being the love song that every mother needs to sing to her girl when she is about to fledge
and
never, as in not once, ever – for helping me understand that all the mysteries of my body and in particular the coil and thrush were never just me.
What will yours be?
I highly recommend that you get a copy of Virgin and find out. You can do so through all of the independent bookshops listed here: :https://geni.us/VirginSigned