Little Miss Glitter⤴

from

Today’s TDC says:

You love creating art, right? You like doing with it us here in the Daily Create, right? Put it on the shelves with this frame (transparent PNG to overlay your image of CreArting DS106 style).

For my first attempt I uploaded my doodle to LunaPic and used the glitterize filter, then use PPT to put the files together. This worked fine on screen, so I used the export as function to save as gif. Again, it all looked fine but when I added it to a Masto toot it looked like a static image.

So here’s my second attempt – a static version of the image uploaded to Giphy and glitter added there.

Why Learning Myths Matter⤴

from @ Memory and Metacognition Updates

Over the last couple of updates, I’ve shared some thoughts on the ‘learning styles myth’. So, what does all of this tell us about metacognition in general?

To my mind, the issue is not just that specific myths about how people learn should be discouraged. The fact that they’re so prevalent in the first place also indicates an issue with the accuracy of how people think about thinking (and learning).

In short, we don’t seem to have an intuitive insight into how learning works, even when it comes to our own learning or that of our classes.

This is a quote that I often share with students:

“…the fact people can be sorted based on their self-reported impressions about what works for them does not make them right about what works for them. One can measure opinions and call them “styles” or anything else you want to call them; the important question is whether doing so provides any predictive leverage.”

(Pashler et al., 2015, p. 123).

The idea that people can have strong but inaccurate views on ‘what works’ is food for thought, and should cause us to be wary, even as experienced educators, to go with our intuitive judgements.

Empirical evidence

An obvious alternative is to proceed in an evidence-based way, using empirical evidence to plan for learning.

Indeed, this is what many of my memory and metacognition updates are based on. Why, for example, do I recommend applying retrieval practice or the spacing effect? The reason is that a strong body of research suggests that these strategies are helpful to learning in a range of contexts.

Again, this is not always obvious. Just as most people commonly accept neuromyths such as learning styles, they often reject or avoid desirable difficulties like retrieval and spacing (see update #99). This shows that intuitive judgement is an unreliable way to proceed.

Through engaging with the evidence, I’ve become wary of my own judgement too, and now try to think with the evidence rather than following more automatic assumptions.

A graphic showing a phone and laptop each with graphs on the screen
Image source: Pixabay

If evidence is more helpful than intuitive judgement, this suggests that educators should, where possible, become more research engaged if they are to make smart judgements about pedagogy, assessment, curriculum and so forth.

Perhaps it also points to a role for teachers engaging in research of their own – something that has become popular in recent years.

I am certainly in favour of well-conducted practitioner action research. However, I have a few concerns, too. If action research is flawed, it could reproduce the same biased intuitive assumptions that I mentioned above, with educators seeing what they want to see.

I’ll say more about the promise and pitfalls of practitioner research in the next update. In the meantime, here is the link to a book I wrote a few years ago on teacher research engagement:


Firth, J. (2019). The teacher’s guide to research. Routledge.


All the best for the coming week,

Jonathan


Last time: More on The Learning Styles Myth – Classroom Implications

I hope you are enjoying Memory and Metacognition Updates. Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work – and consider sharing it with colleagues!! Thank you!

Creative Commons License

Please note that my slides and similar materials are shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. This means you can use or adapt them with attribution for non-commercial purposes. If you wish to use my materials for other purposes, feel free to get in touch.

Why Learning Myths Matter⤴

from @ Memory and Metacognition Updates

Over the last couple of updates, I’ve shared some thoughts on the ‘learning styles myth’. So, what does all of this tell us about metacognition in general?

To my mind, the issue is not just that specific myths about how people learn should be discouraged. The fact that they’re so prevalent in the first place also indicates an issue with the accuracy of how people think about thinking (and learning).

In short, we don’t seem to have an intuitive insight into how learning works, even when it comes to our own learning or that of our classes.

This is a quote that I often share with students:

“…the fact people can be sorted based on their self-reported impressions about what works for them does not make them right about what works for them. One can measure opinions and call them “styles” or anything else you want to call them; the important question is whether doing so provides any predictive leverage.”

(Pashler et al., 2015, p. 123).

The idea that people can have strong but inaccurate views on ‘what works’ is food for thought, and should cause us to be wary, even as experienced educators, to go with our intuitive judgements.

Empirical evidence

An obvious alternative is to proceed in an evidence-based way, using empirical evidence to plan for learning.

Indeed, this is what many of my memory and metacognition updates are based on. Why, for example, do I recommend applying retrieval practice or the spacing effect? The reason is that a strong body of research suggests that these strategies are helpful to learning in a range of contexts.

Again, this is not always obvious. Just as most people commonly accept neuromyths such as learning styles, they often reject or avoid desirable difficulties like retrieval and spacing (see update #99). This shows that intuitive judgement is an unreliable way to proceed.

Through engaging with the evidence, I’ve become wary of my own judgement too, and now try to think with the evidence rather than following more automatic assumptions.

A graphic showing a phone and laptop each with graphs on the screen
Image source: Pixabay

If evidence is more helpful than intuitive judgement, this suggests that educators should, where possible, become more research engaged if they are to make smart judgements about pedagogy, assessment, curriculum and so forth.

Perhaps it also points to a role for teachers engaging in research of their own – something that has become popular in recent years.

I am certainly in favour of well-conducted practitioner action research. However, I have a few concerns, too. If action research is flawed, it could reproduce the same biased intuitive assumptions that I mentioned above, with educators seeing what they want to see.

I’ll say more about the promise and pitfalls of practitioner research in the next update. In the meantime, here is the link to a book I wrote a few years ago on teacher research engagement:


Firth, J. (2019). The teacher’s guide to research. Routledge.


All the best for the coming week,

Jonathan


Last time: More on The Learning Styles Myth – Classroom Implications

I hope you are enjoying Memory and Metacognition Updates. Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work – and consider sharing it with colleagues!! Thank you!

Creative Commons License

Please note that my slides and similar materials are shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. This means you can use or adapt them with attribution for non-commercial purposes. If you wish to use my materials for other purposes, feel free to get in touch.

Teachers need to be more Green Beret⤴

from @ #OnlyLearning

There has been much said about the perceived drop in standing of the teaching profession.

Some of this I put this down to familiarity. A doctor understands the darks arts of medicine, the lay person has no understanding of this as it is cloaked in scientific and latin jargon and they have never opened a living body or studied the internal workings therein.

Similarly, a lawyer understands the dark arts of law. A lay person has no understanding of this as it is cloaked in latin jargon and they have seldom been in a courtroom or studied contracts.

However, though a teacher understands the dark arts of teaching, the lay person knows feels they also understand this having witnessed and experienced its effects as a learner, made clear by the professional using simple English to help them thoughout.

But there is also a lack of confidence shown by the professional teachers themselves. Teachers experience failure, often. But they have also allowed external actors to dictate elements of their practice - most notably, Big Tech companies eager to prove the worth of their tools, spend huge resource on telling teachers why they should adopt their tools, and having done so, on how to use those tools. Their model prioritises efficiency over effectiveness, and might explain the sense of failing that we all feel.

We need to be more like the Royal Marine Commandos. Confident in our training, our skills and our knowledge, and letting noone undermine that confidence. Be more green beret. 

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/digitizegloballtd_digitizefullychargedpodcast-education-ukteachers-activity-7400499878604480512-D90L?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_android&rcm=ACoAAB9p6SQBNObCrP0rMxYQzHcHcBFfX4JxV90

Alice in LaceyLand⤴

from

Today’s TDC asks us to:

You and your favorite book. Combine that pair into art. We want to know the title of the book.

Use text and images; parts of the story; your emotions and drive to read that one.

I chose Alice in Wonderland – one of my many favourite books. I searched for Tenniel’s illustration and photoedited Lacey cat’s head onto the cat. Quick and dirty.

Alice and Lacey
Alice and Lacey flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Robust, resilient, and values-driven.⤴

from @ #OnlyLearning

Amidst a very busy week, I really benefitted from listening to Martin I. Jones, Jonpaul Nevin and Nathalie Pattyn (via the Optimising Human Performance podcast) discuss how good training programmes build both #robustness (how long it takes to knock you down) and #resilience (how quickly you get back up after you are knocked down). 

We often discuss teacher resilience, especially in Initial Teacher Education (#ITE), but we perhaps don't talk as much about the need for robustness. A particularly difficult criteria to identify during the application and interview process.

With Student Teachers currently on placement in schools, Nathalie's comments that screening and interviewing can only accomplish so much, was a great reminder of one of the core strengths of the #PGDE school experience module: the chance for qualified teachers to scrutinise the #values and #character of a student teacher before we potentially accept them into the profession (à la the GTC Scotland standards)

If you want to listen to this insightful conversation, check out https://lnkd.in/ePbnpEZF 

A One-Team ethos in Education⤴

from @ #OnlyLearning

Dr. Steve Munby's advice to School Leaders and Senior Leaders when asked, "How can we change the system?" has lived rent-free in my head for over three years because of the power of the embodied sentiment:

"Don't try and think you can change the whole system, but you can operate within your sphere of influence.

Some fundamental things... believe and behave that children's learning in other schools is as important as children's learning in your own school. And once you really accept that we're here to enable all children to be powerful learners, not just the ones that happen to be in our school - that's a fundamental shift in approach.

It means, when a school down the road is struggling, you don't say "Oh great! The parents will send their children to my school". You pick up the phone and say, "How can I help?" and "Come and do things together".

Because improvement of all schools in the area - and the learning of all - that's important".

[from Ep.67 of Changing Conversations podcast with Sarah Philp (CPsychol) and Billy Burke, 12th June 2022]

It came to mind again recently, when I was reading Langley Sharp MBE 's "The Habit of Excellence", in which he wrote, "Fighting power in the modern Army rests not on individual regiments ploughing their own furrow, but a one-team ethos across different cap badges, Arms and services, which accords due respect and recognition to the contribution each makes"

Now that is a mindset we can and should all try to embrace.


Blog Post Title Generator⤴

from

Today’s TDC asks us to

Use the Portent Title Generator to randomly generate a title about DS106…then WRITE THAT POST!

So I did. Amusingly I got this prompt

Portent Title Generator
Portent Title Generator flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Amusing, that is, as I usually complete the activity soon after it is published at 10am my time, but today I’ve been caught up in meetings and with workmen, so have only just sat down to look at it at 3pm.

Anyway – here it is. Another post from me talking about how I love to do the Daily Create every day because it stimulates my creative mind and helps to take me away from the daily grind. And because practice doesn’t make perfect, but it does make better.

Evaluating your own practice (educators) – finding and checking information⤴

from @ DigiLearn

Assessing your own practice  It is important to not only develop effective information literacy skills but also to assess how these can impact our own everyday work. Understanding how information literacy development can bring positive benefits to our pedagogies and to our classrooms is a critical step towards embedding this into our wider everyday professional …