Recognising the power and joy of being human . . . some thoughts from #digifest2026⤴

from

Due to circumstances outwith my control (yes dear reader outwith is a real word), I had a slightly truncated visit to this year’s Digifest.  I also had to spend quite a bit longer of trains, and train platforms so on my way home I was listening to quite a variety of podcasts/live radio, and reflecting on the time I had there.

As with any conference/festival/event ( I think Digifest is actually a mix of all three of these) the “best part” is always catching up with people in person.  I was there to be part of a session showcasing the work from Phase 1 & 2 of the Jisc Beyond Blended Pilot programme.  I’ve written before about how special this programme is ( and yes of course I am biased), but one of the really special things about it is the sense of community, of openness, empathy, sharing and fun that has almost instantly been there from our first in person meeting.  The very human element of this work was exemplified by the hugs and laughs shared by the representatives the pilots as we all met up in our designated room before the session. 

We had all just come from the first key note by Melato Wijsen, climate activist, change maker and founder of Youthtopia.  Melato is passionate about supporting young people to be change makers; about having more space in all educational settings for intergenerational partnership opportunities, and allowing more space to, and talk about failing.  But essentially what she was advocating for was more a more human centred approach in education to global (and local) issues that impact all of us, and allow different (younger) voices to be heard and have an impact. 

All quite challenging in our current political climate – how can you speak truth to power when certain power doesn’t need feel the need to listen to anyone outside its own echo chamber?  But we do still need to try, and as Melato said we do need to have new narratives, new stories to tell and share about the reality of education today. (BTW We have some great stories from real people about the conversations and work they are doing to transform learning and teaching from the Beyond Blended pilots).

We also need to be wary of some stories we are being told and sold, particularly about AI. The wonderful and self proclaimed Cassandra of EdTech Audrey Watters, is always reminding us that some of the loudest stories we are currently being t/sold about AI, aren’t new but are in fact perpetuating old stories and “visions” for the future of education . These stories are predicated on profit – not people. They certainly don’t tell this kind of story about the human cost of training AI.

So, I was thinking about all of this whilst almost dozing off listening to a podcast about toothache (don’t judge me) on the train home, when near the end of the episode, one of the hosts starting talking about poetry. I know, quite a leap from toothache, but bear with me, there is a point here. He recalled how he had recently seen an old interview with Seamus Heaney where he was talking about a book he edited call By Heart ( I haven’t been able to find said book yet). The idea of the book was to encourage people to learn poetry by heart. Heaney was asked if he thought that learning poems would make someone a better person, to which he replied, no, but I think it might you better at being a person. What a brilliant answer, and how apt for some of the discussion around AI in education right now. Isn’t education fundamentally about making us all better people?

Danny Liu’s keynote (which I watched remotely) on day 2 also picked up on this theme. He reminded us that as we navigate our way through our current AI cluttered landscape, we need make space across the curriculum (and beyond) to celebrate and support the values that make us human in ways that only humans can. As Audrey recently pointed out, the qualities we value about being human aren’t actually replicated in so called human centred AI.

So, let’s value teaching and teachers and not boil “learning” down into “efficient”, self accessed chunks. Let’s value and create spaces to develop criticality in conversations; for equality and respect of different points of view but also an acceptance of facts. Let’s value and create safe spaces for people to fail and to learn how to learn from those experiences – not just be knocked down and out by them. Let’s value the fact that some things – like writing – are hard. Let’s value the joy of bringing people together to share the highs and lows of work, and life (thank you Digifest for doing just that).

Maybe if we have that focus around the value of collectively becoming better people, then we will be able create and tell more stories, so that more young people will have stories like Melato’s and we really will have a better future to look forward to. And being “only human” not, augmented with AI is something I certainly want to value and cherish for as long as I can.

Cue cheesy 80’s music. . .

Food Face Plate⤴

from

My food face plate for today’s TDC

Food Face Plate
Food Face Plate flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

I am amused to notice that this is almost identical to the last time this I did this challege

Fruit face
Fruit face flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (BY-NC-SA 2.0) license

The Surrealist Compliment Generator⤴

from

Frog under umbrella
Frog under umbrella flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Today’s TDC asks us to

Visit The Surrealist Compliment Generator and see what compliment it offers you. Then use this to make some art or a poem to amuse us all.

I reloaded it a few times before getting this

La pluie de vos insultes n’atteint pas le parapluie de mon indifference.

Which I think roughly means that “The rain of your insults does not reach the umbrella of my indifference.” So here’s a frog hiding from the rain,

Purposes of Education, Part 2⤴

from @ Memory and Metacognition Updates

Hello! I hope you are doing well. I know I rather disappeared after promising to do ‘part 2’ of this topic a week later (part 1 here). As mentioned on the odd occasion, I’ve been working on a book, and the impending deadline had to take precedence! The manuscript is due with the published next Friday.

The book title is The Psychology of Education, and it will cover a broad range of issues. However, as I’ve been redrafting the final chapter, I’ve been reflecting particularly on the topic I shared last time. It seems to me that by applying psychology to education, there is the potential to improve things, not just in formal education but across society.

That has to be the aim, anyway. Is it realistic? I guess that depends on how much we believe that psychological interventions can change people, for example by impacting on knowledge, skills, metacognition and how well people think.

Critical Thinking

In the context of learners’ capacities (or skills) that I discussed last time, arguably the most discussed is critical thinking. I see this term so often in educational contexts: posters in school corridors, curriculum documents, course goals for students at university, and many more.

What is the basis for the appeal of critical thinking?

  1. One is that it’s supposed that critical thinkers will play a useful role in society, perhaps helping to solve future challenges.

  2. Closely related is the idea that lacking critical thinking makes citizens prone to faulty thinking. For example, Pennycook et al. (2023) have discussed how cognitive sophistication can make people resistant to science and political misinformation.

There is also, it seems, a more negative reason: it is widely assumed that the knowledge covered in academic courses is subject to the unpredictability of the future in general and of career paths in particular. What’s the benefit of studying chemistry, for example, if I am not going to be a chemist?

This is a tough question to answer, and the most common response I see is that even if you don’t use your knowledge of chemistry, the process of learning it will at least develop certain thinking skills.

An obvious problem with this is that it’s hard to justify the place of any particular subject as part of the curriculum if they all develop the same transferable skills (e.g. critical thinking).


Close-up image of a test tube in flame
Source: Pixabay

Much to unpack

Like a lot in education, the ideas above have a lot to unpack. And while the answers can’t be found in cognitive science alone, there are a few relevant principles we can consider:

Teaching skills through subjects

I previously mentioned Willingham’s view that critical thinking can’t be taught. However, a more positive view of transfer in cognitive science is that it can be achieved if we go about things the right way (see update #114). It is widely agreed that when it comes to study skills, these are most effectively developed in the context of particular disciplines, rather than as generic courses. Likewise, creativity is often seen as domain specific (see update #28)

In a similar way, it makes sense that we would develop critical thinking in the context of academic subjects and other activities. It might make sense to stop viewing it as a broad skill but rather as as a set of many sub-skills that depend on the domain – a person can be good at thinking critically about science, for example, but poor at thinking critically about politics.

How useful is knowledge?

Second, just because a student is not planning to be a chemist (for example), can we conclude that it’s really not useful to know about Chemistry? There are any number of ways that (well-chosen) knowledge it could come up in one’s life. Further, knowledge is a prerequisite to thinking (which is really Willingham’s point about critical thinking being hard to teach – it’s hard if we don’t know enough!).

I think Schwarz and colleagues put this in quite a balanced way: “A goal of much formal schooling is to provide students a foundation of knowledge on which they can build new knowledge once they leave school… Except for very narrow training, people will need to continue learning new ideas and skills once they have left the confines of immediate instruction. People grow into their jobs, they change jobs, and the world changes around them” (Schwartz et al., 2009, p. 37).

To conclude

In general, I agree that critical thinking is important, but I’m not keen on the educational discourse that constantly lionises this skill without taking account of how it actually functions on a cognitive level. While strategies can be developed, it makes more sense overall to view it as tied to memories and knowledge. It is also worth considering the many different processes and contexts it involves, rather than seeing it as one generic skill.

Perhaps that means we can celebrating subjects for what they teach, rather than always looking for skills to justify their place in the curriculum.

So … back to book writing/editing! I’ll share more about that another time (possibly after my deadline).


All the best for the coming week,

Jonathan


Last time: Purposes of Education

I hope you are enjoying Memory and Metacognition Updates. Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work – and consider sharing it with colleagues!! Thank you!

Please note that my slides and similar materials are shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. This means you can use or adapt them with attribution for non-commercial purposes. If you wish to use my materials for other purposes, feel free to get in touch.

International Women’s Day 2026- Molly Fergusson⤴

from @ Melissa Highton

It was my joy, once again to celebrate this day with a room opening.

Naming spaces on campus after women is crucial for several reasons:

  • Recognition of Achievements: It honors the achievements of women in STEM and other fields, despite the challenges they faced.
  • Historical Context: It provides a historical context to the University’s history, highlighting the contributions of women throughout history.
  • Promotion of Diversity: It promotes diversity and inclusion on campus, reflecting the University’s commitment to diversity and representation.
  • Inspiration: It serves as inspiration for future generations, encouraging them to pursue their passions and contribute to society.You can’t be what you can’t see.
  • Public Awareness: It raises public awareness about the contributions of women and encourages a more inclusive society.

By naming spaces on campus after women, the University of Edinburgh and other institutions can contribute to a more equitable and inspiring environment for all.

The University of Edinburgh owns more than 550 buildings throughout the city of Edinburgh across five campuses

On extensive campuses the size of Edinburgh’s the space is often shifting. I am pleased that ISG and Estates are able to continue a rolling programme of upgrades to teaching spaces.

And it is when a room like this gets a significant upgrade, or change of use, to bring it into the teaching estate and the care of ISG, we have an opportunity to give it an inspirational name.

There are dozens of rooms across the university named after men, few, so very few, named after women.

And this is a running battle . As the estate changes and shifts we make some gains and we take some losses.

ISG moving out of Argyle House means we have lost  4 spaces named for women who worked as pioneering digital librarians and Bletchley Park code breakers. Hopefully we will manage to re-instate them in Forrest Hill.

It was lovely to be back at KB campus. I am pleased to say, we have already named

The Mary Somerville Data Centre 

The Xia Pesu training room

The Charlotte Murchison Lecture theatre in Murchison House.

And now this Molly Fergusson room, a woman we have heard so much about today.

In preparing for today, and learning about Molly’s work, I have been thinking a bit about bridges, and building bridges.

I had an auntie who was a radical feminist and she would say to me

‘may the bridges I burn , light your way.

Which I thought sounded very cool. But I think generally, it is probably better if we build the bridges, cross them and then leave them unburned for others who follow across.

Unless they are your enemies, in which case you definitely want to be burning them.

Bridges are landmarks that define the identity of towns and cities, and a source of civic pride for the people who live there. Bridges can do more for communities than improving connectivity and promoting active travel, people feel very strongly about them.

The Society of Civil Engineers say:

“Bridge projects that seek to be socially transformative will not necessarily cost more than those that focus purely on building the bridge.”

And that is how if see these room naming opportunities. The fit out and design of the room is not more expensive for having the opportunity to also be socially transformative in celebrating  our community role models. By making and naming this place we can signal something about the university’s aspirational values for women and girls.

Tunnel Vision⤴

from

Last week I took a walk down to Victoria Park, and took this picture as I was walking through the underpass

Tunnel Vision
Tunnel Vision flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Today’s TDC asks us to say “what’s at the end of this tunnel? Is this a friendly monster hoping for cookies or a scary beast waiting to bite you? Tell us the story of the eyes at the end of the tunnel.” Here’s the doodle that came out of my pens.

Victoria Park Monster
Victoria Park Monster flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Acrostic⤴

from

Cat on a lap
Cat on a lap flickr photo by NomadWarMachine shared under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) license

Loudly shouting for food and treats
Always in the way during Zoom meetings
Creating havoc when the bathroom door is closed
Eyes looking daggers when I stroke the other cat
Yet cuddly and affectionate when she gets her own way

For TDC5168